Saturday, January 19, 2013

Of truth of chiaroscuro

"Be so kind, on the first bright, sunny day after you have read this, as to look for a white [washed?] cottage, on one side of which the sun falls as directly as may be, but so as yet to get slightly and obliquely at another side. On the high light you will find that you  cannot  see  the  projecting  granulation,  but  in  the  oblique  light  you  can  see  every pebble  separately.  Whatever  detail  or  projections  are  on  the  high  light,  as  the  sun penetrates into every chink and cranny of them, can cast no shadows, and have no dark sides and,  therefore,  are  indistinctly  and  imperfectly  seen,  and  indeed,  unless  very large and important, are not seen at all; whence arises the general rule. There can be no detail on the high light. It is all blaze. But whatever projections and details exist on the surface turned obliquely to the light, each, however small, has its dark side and shadow, and every one is seen, more and more distinctly as the object is turned more and more from the light. The result of this is, that as every object not polished has more or less of texture on its surface, and nearly all have roughness and projections, and detail in some degree, a general tone of shadow is obtained on these oblique surfaces far deeper than could be accounted for by the mere fact of the oblique fall of the light, and they sink, practically,  into  what  artists call Middle  Tint.  Again,  the  Dark  Side, though  entirely inaccessible to the direct lightŕis very strongly affected by the reflected light, which as it were fills the whole atmosphere, and illuminates every object open and exposed to it; and it is also very often so energetically illumined by accidental lights that its mass is broken up, and it usually becomes also merged in what artists call Middle Tint. But that part of it which is accidentally Shadow is usually, by its position, inaccessible even  to the reflected light, and always more inaccessible than the Dark Side. It is therefore, in near  objects,  and  in  sunlight,  so  dark  in  comparison  with  the  high  lights,  that  their relative degrees of intensity can be scarcely expressed with real truth, except by the jet black of  chalk on white paper."

Hence shadows are in reality, when the sun is shining, the most conspicuous things in a landscape, next to the highest   lights.   All   forms are understood  and explained chiefly by their agency: the roughness of the bark of a tree, for instance, is not seen in the light, nor in the shade; it is only seen between the two, where  the shadows of the ridges explain  it. And hence, if we have to express vivid light, our very first aim must be to get the shadows sharp and visible; and this is not to be done by blackness (though indeed chalk on white paper is the only thing which comes up to the intensity of real shadows), but by  keeping  them  perfectly  flat,  keen,  and  even.  A  very  pale shadow, if it be quite flat, if it conceal the details of the objects it crosses, if it be grey and cold compared with their colour, and very  sharp-edged,  will  be  far  more  conspicuous,  and  make everything out of it look a great deal more like sunlight, than a shadow ten times its depth, shaded off at the  edge,  and  confounded  with  the  colour  of  the  objects  on which  it  falls.

Modern Painters I

No comments:

Post a Comment